Digital Advocacy · United States
Herald Group's Van Etten says advocacy teams should bring creative strategy in at the start
The firm's chief digital strategist argues that companies and trade associations should stop locking messages first and then deciding how to distribute them, and should judge digital work by substance rather than reach alone.
Public Affairs Trends Staff · 2026-11-16

Based on reporting from theheraldgroup.com.
Companies and trade associations planning their 2027 advocacy work should stop treating creative as a late-stage production step, The Herald Group Chief Digital Strategist and Partner Todd Van Etten wrote in an analysis of lessons from the midterm campaigns.
Van Etten argued that the usual sequence — set policy objectives, finalize messages, then decide how to distribute them — no longer fits how audiences encounter political information. "The format, messenger, and narrative structure influence how an issue is understood and should be considered alongside the policy objective from the beginning," he wrote.
The Herald Group is a public affairs and strategic communications firm that works with companies, trade associations and advocacy organizations. Van Etten's recommendations are aimed at those organizations as they build digital advocacy strategies for the year ahead.
Start with the creative, not after the message is locked
The implications for public affairs teams go beyond producing more conversational videos, Van Etten wrote. They challenge when creative strategy enters the process. Creative development, he wrote, often begins only after central communications decisions are already made.
The midterm campaigns are the backdrop for that advice. Van Etten wrote that candidates and politicians from both parties often traded scripted, "traditional" political ads for direct-to-camera social videos, familiar settings and appearances alongside online creators. He pointed to Zohran Mamdani's 2025 mayoral campaign as an earlier example of professionally produced content that still felt spontaneous and relatable, and said the approach spread more widely in 2026.
He also cautioned that a more conversational format is not a shortcut around substance. "The challenge for communicators is to preserve the substance and transparency of advocacy while adapting its presentation to changing information habits," Van Etten wrote.
Authentic-looking work still takes research and testing
"Authentic-looking communication isn't necessarily inexpensive or spontaneous," he wrote. It can require considerable research, creative direction and editorial judgment, he argued, to make a complicated issue understandable without reducing it to a slogan. Message testing, he wrote, can help confirm the messaging pillars and pain points needed for organic social content.
That is a different investment model than treating a polished policy message as the main product and the creative as a later expense. Organizations, Van Etten wrote, should move beyond the assumption that a well-developed policy message, paired with sufficient advertising, will automatically connect with an audience.
Let organic and paid work inform each other
Van Etten also urged organizations to rethink the relationship between organic content and paid advertising. Organic engagement, he wrote, can reveal audience questions and information gaps, while paid media can test creative approaches beyond an organization's existing audience.
Neither guarantees credibility, he wrote, and performance should be judged against substantive communications objectives rather than reach alone.
"Instead of treating creative production as a fixed expense followed by a larger media buy, organizations should consider how content development, testing and distribution inform one another throughout a campaign," he wrote.
"The strategic value isn't simply creating more content," Van Etten added. "It's developing a deeper understanding of what makes political information relevant, credible, and worth consuming."
As organizations prepare for 2027, he wrote, that means investing earlier in creative strategy, understanding the relationships audiences have with different information sources, and recognizing that the way a message is presented can be as important as how widely it is distributed.
According to his firm biography, Van Etten leads The Herald Group's digital department, including online advertising, social media programs, analytics and creative direction. He previously served as vice president of digital at The Advocacy Group and as director of digital strategy in Burson-Marsteller's Washington office.
Share this
LinkedInXFacebookEmail