Advocacy
AI didn't invent advocacy fraud but made it cheaper, CiviClick CEO Chazz Clevinger says
Pointing to fake comments in the FCC's 2017 net neutrality docket, Clevinger told Public Affairs Trends the test is whether a real, verified person stands behind each message.
Public Affairs Trends Staff · 2026-11-13
On the podcast: Moving Beyond Form Letters: How AI is Personalizing Public Affairs

Based on reporting from Public Affairs Trends podcast.
The nightmare of an AI-generated flood of fake public comments isn't hypothetical, Chazz Clevinger, founder and CEO of the advocacy technology company CiviClick, said on the Public Affairs Trends episode on AI and personalized advocacy.
"The risk is real. I won't insult anyone's intelligence by pretending otherwise because it's already happened before generative AI even existed," Clevinger said.
He pointed to the Federal Communications Commission's 2017 net neutrality proceeding. New York Attorney General Letitia James found in 2021 that nearly 18 million of the more than 22 million comments the FCC received were fake. Three lead generators agreed to pay more than $4.4 million in penalties and disgorgement, the attorney general's office said, and three more companies agreed to pay $615,000 in 2023.
"AI didn't invent fraud, it happened long before it existed. It did make old fraud cheaper," Clevinger said.
That distinction should shape regulation, he argued. "If you regulate the drafting tool instead of trying to stop the fake submissions themselves, you punish the legitimate constituents and the consultants and actually miss the real problem," he said.
His line between advocacy and astroturf is a single question. "Is there a real verified human being who authorized the message and stands behind it? If yes, it's petitioning," Clevinger said.
CiviClick uses real-time address and identity validation, logs timestamps and IP addresses, and uses TrustedForm certificates from ActiveProspect to document actions, he said. He described the certificates as "a third-party audit that provides independent validation that an action was real."
Clevinger was also skeptical of list-building shortcuts. Co-registration can produce names quickly, he said, but "real names without real intent are often useless," and a generic message from someone who can't stand behind it "discounts the entire program."
He said the industry has to police itself. "That's why self-policing is existential in this industry," Clevinger said, adding that he supports "reasonable verification standards for what enters every official channel and comment docket." He praised the public comment dockets on Regulations.gov, where anyone can read submissions. "Sunlight is legitimate operators' best friend," he said.
Listen to Chazz Clevinger's full Public Affairs Trends interview on AI, authenticity and advocacy fraud.
Share this
LinkedInXFacebookEmail