Advocacy
Congressional offices tally identical form letters as one data point, CiviClick's Chazz Clevinger says
The former Senate correspondence staffer told Public Affairs Trends that AI should draft from an interview with each advocate, who approves every word, not paraphrase a lobbyist's letter.
Public Affairs Trends Staff · 2026-11-13
On the podcast: Moving Beyond Form Letters: How AI is Personalizing Public Affairs

Based on reporting from Public Affairs Trends podcast.
Hundreds of identical advocacy emails can count for no more than one, Chazz Clevinger, founder and CEO of CiviClick, said on the Public Affairs Trends podcast.
Clevinger said he started his career answering constituent correspondence in a U.S. Senate office. In the past, he said, "500 identical form letters would just get tallied as one data point in a spreadsheet, whereas a letter from a nurse describing what policy actually means for her patients gets read and flagged."
Survey data from congressional staff points the same way. In a Congressional Management Foundation survey, 51% of staff said a form email would have "some" or "a lot" of influence, compared with 88% for an individualized email, CMF President Bradford Fitch wrote in Roll Call.
"For 20 years, grassroots ran on a brutal trade-off where you could either have scale or authenticity, but not both," Clevinger said. "AI has killed that trade-off."
But he said many vendors use AI the wrong way. "They're just using AI to paraphrase a form letter and spinning the same 3 talking points into just unique variations," Clevinger said. "Staff can smell that."
"The right answer was to reverse the direction of the AI. Don't point it just at the lawmaker, point it at the advocate," he said. CiviClick's approach runs advocates through a brief interview about their work, community and experience with the issue, and keeps "90-95% of the core messaging points" of the campaign's letter, he said.
The advocate has the final say. "Every message gets reviewed and edited if the advocate wants it to be. They have to approve it," Clevinger said. His test: "Could the advocate read that message aloud to their representative's face and stand behind every sentence?"
Specific stories carry the most weight, he said. "A pharmacist in Winston-Salem, North Carolina, explaining a reimbursement rule, its real-world effect on them, will outlast 100 messages that are just a repeat of what a Washington lobbyist has to say."
For teams ready to try it, Clevinger advised starting small: "Pilot it in one low-risk campaign, not a platform-wide overhaul." He said to "track action completion rates, message uniqueness, and how offices respond" and compare the results with past form-letter campaigns.
Strategy stays with people, he said. AI is "a brilliant analyst," Clevinger said, "but it's a terrible general."
Hear Chazz Clevinger's full Public Affairs Trends conversation on moving beyond form letters.
Share this
LinkedInXFacebookEmail