Tuesday, November 17, 2026 · Government • Public Policy • Public Affairs
Public Affairs Trends Podcast logo

Reputation Management

Guarantees and editor 'connections' are red flags in a Wikipedia consultant, Jonathan Rick says

Rick told Public Affairs Trends the five questions to ask before hiring Wikipedia help, and said about 75% of people who want a page aren't yet eligible.

Public Affairs Trends Staff · 2026-11-13

On the podcast: Why AI Loves Wikipedia: What Communicators Need to Know

Jonathan Rick, Washington-based ghostwriter and Wikipedia consultant
Photo: Jonathan Rick

Based on reporting from Public Affairs Trends podcast.

Any Wikipedia consultant who promises results should be shown the door, Jonathan Rick, a Washington-based Wikipedia consultant with about 20 years in the field, said on the Public Affairs Trends podcast.

Rick offered five questions to ask before hiring help.

The first: "Do you guarantee success? If they say yes, that's your cue to exit stage left," he said. "Anybody who promises or guarantees a result is misrepresenting both the encyclopedia and what they're capable of."

The second is whether the consultant has connections to editors or administrators. If they say yes or dodge the question, "that's the second clearest sign you're dealing with a con artist," Rick said.

Third is price. "If they quote you $1,000 or less, they're churning and burning clients rather than providing high-touch services," he said. Rick said "somewhere in the neighborhood of like 75% of people who come to me who want a Wikipedia page aren't currently eligible," and that "a third of my clients come to me after having been burned by someone who gives them a cutthroat rate."

Fourth is whether the consultant offers to spin the facts. "If the consultant promises to whitewash your history, they're selling you snake oil," Rick said. Wikipedia "is not concerned with truth with a capital T. It's concerned with what reliable sources have reported."

Negative coverage can be framed but not removed, he said. The best argument is that it gets coverage in proportion to the press it received, a principle Wikipedia calls due weight.

The last question is how the consultant discloses conflicts of interest. "If they don't disclose, then hiring them jeopardizes your own reputation," Rick said. Wikipedia requires paid editors to disclose who is paying them under its paid-contribution disclosure policy.

Most organizations that want a page aren't ready because of how Wikipedia defines notability, he said. People "conflate being accomplished with being notable," Rick said. "The only thing that matters is media coverage."

His advice for teams starting out is to work on press first. "The road to Wikipedia lies through media coverage," he said. "That's a marathon, not a sprint."

Hear Jonathan Rick's full Public Affairs Trends conversation on hiring Wikipedia help and AI.

Share this

LinkedInXFacebookEmail